By gathering both statistical data and narratives, then compiling them into an account of the spiritual struggles faced by LGBTQ+ individuals as they work their way through the legal system from arrest to incarceration to release and re-integration, I will show faith groups how Jesus’ Great Commandment and other scriptural texts, including non-Christian texts, compel us to be supporters of, and advocates for, our siblings in this process. Jesus says that as we visit those in prison we visit him, but freedom for the imprisoned is also a sign of the day of jubilee, of God’s reign of peace. The prophet Micah says “Do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with the Divine;” any examination of current-day US prison policy demonstrates a lack of justice for all caught in it, most especially for LGBTQ+ individuals. Together with a LGBTQ+ person on the inside, we will formulate theological statements that elucidate the spiritual experiences of incarcerated LGBTQ+ people. Using these statements, we can then, again in partnership with those on the inside (“Nothing about us without us”) create a project to convey the spiritual needs and desires of those on the inside to those in the free world, enabling them to spiritually support their incarcerated LGBTQ+ siblings.