Reflecting on Vulnerability, Authenticity, and Shame in Church Settings

“… response to congregational and social struggle? Where are the points of consonance and dissonance specifically with Lutheran (ELCA) theology? ”

Team Members/Contributors

Sarah K Ciavarri Augustana Health Care Center of Apple Valley and the Apple Valley Villa Contact Me

About this pastoral study project

The church, as representative of Christ in a broken world, is called to respond to hurt and struggle, both corporate and individual. Yet, culture is shifting and the role of moral authority that Christianity played for centuries is declining, along with membership for mainline denominations. In these uncertain times, fear, blame, and shame can impede action. Simultaneously, beyond the church, several thought leaders are encouraging people to own their stories of brokenness, to be authentic, and to practice self-acceptance. Diverse writing on vulnerability, authenticity, and shame is starting to influence, and resonate deeply with, people in the church. My project reflects on this intersection of faith and emerging thought: What does growing interest in vulnerability, authenticity,and shame mean for ministry? How is it impacting pastoral and ecclesial response to congregational and social struggles? Where are the points of consonance and dissonance specifically with Lutheran (ELCA) theology? Through reading, personal reflection and writing, and conversation with at least six Lutheran theologians, my project explores these questions. I will also compose at least four songs integrating these concepts with my story. I will publish my insights online and submit to a resource like Living Lutheran to start a wider conversation.